It doesn’t matter that a vast majority of the general public and international acting community think — make that know — Meryl Streep is the finest actress to grace a screen since the talkies. And, it doesn’t matter that her performance far outshines that of any other actress on the planet.
She must sit and smile and be grateful just to know that she’s the superior actress, even when saddled with being lesser so, by those who are not as talented, or as accomplished as she.
(And by ‘she’ I mean those of ‘you’ still up there in my opening line, imagining yourself as Meryl Streep.)
The point is, being the best at what you do is never enough to win the acclaim of those around you.
Indeed, the chances are good it will elicit exactly the opposite results, regardless of your profession. Because that’s the nature of awards and winning and — especially for the craft of writing — book reviews.
I say ‘especially’ because book reviews and letters to the editor are the two areas of the media where everyone, regardless of their intent, intelligence, or lack thereof, can participate as an authority.
And, because of this, both (along with the installation of the five star system) have become the weapon of choice for malcontents.
The question we all need to ask ourselves is simple: Am I complicit?
The answer is YES if you:
(1) Write a good review for your friend or relative, simply because she is your friend or relative, not because her/his book is as good as the review you’ve given.
(2) Award a five star rating to a book because it was authored by a friend or relative, not because her/his book is as good as you’ve rated it.
(3) Issue a bad review for a book you haven’t read.
(4) Issue a bad review for a book you haven’t read because you carry a grudge against the author, or you have a friend who carries a grudge.
(5) Award a low star rating for a book you haven’t read.
(6) Award a low star rating for a book you haven’t read because you carry a grudge against the author, or you have a friend who carries a grudge.
(7) Sabotage an author whose publisher is in competition with your publisher.
(8) Sabotage an author for revenge.
(9) Sabotage an author out of jealousy.
(10) Sabotage an author because you can, and that ability gives you power.
About now you’re wondering how this essay became about you instead of those so-in-sos who gave you a bad review.
That’s the thing.
When it comes to writing — just as when it comes to all other areas of life — it is never about what is done to you.
Rather, it is always about what you did to help create an atmosphere where such injustices flourish.
And, by ‘you’ I mean ‘me’, and ‘us’, and ‘we’.
Like every journey, this one takes one step by one person at a time.
It takes resolve.
It takes a decision by each of us to (1) refrain from giving credit where credit isn’t due, and (2) refrain from sabotaging those we don’t like, and (3) choose to learn from those whom we consider to be more talented, more creative, or more accomplished, and (4) mentor all who are receptive, in an effort to improve our craft and our writing community.
It isn’t necessary to like every writer. But we must try to respect every person who makes the effort, takes the time, and risks the rejection that results from writing a book, regardless of its caliber
And, if we can do that, we will know
our own worth.
And, if we can do that, we will rejoice
in the success of others.
And, if we can do that, we will accept, as a burden,
that there will always be those whose low self-esteem,
jealousy, envy, ego, or anger won’t allow them
any other recourse
but to lash out.
And if we can do that, we’ll realize, as a blessing,
that the next essay, article, story, or book we write
will be better because of it.
And if we can do that, we will each,
we will all, know what it’s like to be
# # #
by Marguerite Quantaine © 2015
PLEASE SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS BY SELECTING
REPLY. I’m all eyes and heart.
Please share on Facebook and Twitter.
Marguerite Quantaine is an essayist and author.
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK without reading the first 7 chapters for FREE on Amazon to determine the caliber of writing and quality of the story.